Insight

Live Action vs. Animation

live action

Congratulations on deciding to make a video. You are clearly a person of great taste and vision.

But effective video and animation can take many forms, each with their own idiosyncrasies, so there are some more decisions to make. The biggest of these is whether to create a live action film, an animation, or a hybrid of both.

What’s the difference?

I know this sounds like a silly question but bear with us.

‘Live action’ is anything that is filmed with a camera, including Go Pros, drones, phones and security cameras. This will include specially shot footage of course, but also library footage. There are specialist libraries offering everything from satellite images to new sand sport footage to wildlife photography. These are handy, but libraries charge for licensing their shots so it’s not always cheaper than a bespoke shoot.

Also, you’ll get better banter from a film crew.

live action
live action

‘Animation’ encompasses everything from simple 2D animated ‘dynamic text’to photo-realistic Computer-Generated Images (CGI) as seen in blockbuster movies.

The choice of animation style will depend on a blend of your stylistic aspirations and budget. High quality animation is notoriously labour intensive but bearing in mind the average duration of most corporate content (So, you want to make a corporate video?) cost and time may not be a barrier.

Dynamic text
©

Dynamic text

2D animation
©White Turtle Studios

2D animation

3D animation
©Dreamworks

3D animation

Cinema-quality CGI
©Wingnut/New Line

Cinema-quality CGI

‘Hybrid’ options involve adding animated elements (often called Motion Graphics) over the top of live action footage (which become known as background ‘plates’) OR the insertion of live action elements into a CGI environment, usually using the magic of green screen technology.

Echo
Shell Studio

What’s your story?

Animation is cool. But is it the most effective way to tell your story?

Video is excellent at creating and provoking emotional responses.

The correct application of documentary techniques or well-acted dramatic scenes can provoke strong responses.

Family Mumbai

Even a straightforward address to the camera, given directly to the audience, can have great power if well delivered.

It is possible but much harder to achieve the same effect with animation, without spending a lot of time (that’s why Pixar films are so good).

Live action is also the only way to go if you want to show real people and situations.

Karen

Some messages require that authenticity. Animation is excellent for illustrating things that cannot be seen by the naked eye (or naked camera).

Taking a more graphic approach can simplify complex mechanisms or concepts and help highlight the items you want to give attention to. It can also give life to dry information or statistics (literally animating them).

Gilenlivet

What’s the downside?

As any boy scout knows, you need to Be Prepared. Whether you are animating or filming that means having a clear script in advance and agreeing on the desired end result before you start production. But there are some challenges that are specific to each approach.

Shooting live action video is subject to things outside our control: weather, operational issues, unexpected noises and at some locations, safety challenges. Good pre-planning will mitigate against these.

Rain
Camera

Shooting can take time to set up, light properly and rehearse, and we will probably need to do more than one take. If we are shooting at your premises, there is inevitably a degree of disruption (again, planning will minimise this).

However, we can shoot more content in a day than an animator can hope to animate, so live action is usually significantly faster to get from script to finished programme.

Plexus Super Hero Fire

Animation has a major advantage – you can create any scene and do anything within it. But it also has a major disadvantage: nothing exists yet! Every character, prop, and environment (we call these ‘Assets’) must be designed and created from scratch.

The more realistic you want it to look the longer this takes (although it is possible to save time by converting existing CAD models or buying pre-made digital assets).

Stork AOD

Let’s Talk

A chat won’t cost anything. We will take the time to weigh up what you want to say with how best to say it.

We will recommend the best approach to fit your schedule and budget and write the script that works with that approach

What’s your story?

S2N showreel

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.

Menu